For Crimin' Out Loud:
(Short # 170 in Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk: The Columbia Shorts of The Three Stooges)
This
is it: the last new footage I’ll see of Shemp as a Stooge. What a
career he had: he and his brother Moe worked w/ and w/o Ted Healy in
vaudeville in the 20’s-Larry joined in ’28. He left the allegedly
abusive Healy in ’32 and had a decent career solo in film until he and
Moe’s brother Curly passed. Originally a temporary move, he stayed with
them until he died via heart attack on November, 22, 1955 at the age of
60. What a trio those Horwitz brothers were in show business; all three
are still beloved today. Shemp is entertaining in a different way than
his brother Curly.
Crimin’ is a remake of 1949’s Who Done It? That
is one of the best of the Shemp era. The first five minutes are
all-new. “The Stooges do the 50’s version of forensics” is a phrase I
never thought would be written but it’s true. The usual hijinks occur
but it’s still nice to see the trio one last time; then, we get the rest
of Who Done It?; it’s framed this time as Emil Sitka’s Mr. Goodrich is a
councilman who was kidnapped by The Phantom Gang, including Christine
McIntyre as the femme fatale and Duke York as Nikko, a scary-looking
giant goon.
To copy and paste from the review of Who Done It?:
“The
Stooges beat each other up even more than usual, there is an onslaught
of puns, they spoof the trope of scary houses having false panels in
walls and hiding behind paintings... there was what TV Tropes refers to
as the “Poisoned Chalice Switcheroo.” McIntyre poisons a drink and
offers it to Shemp; they distract each other and switch the drinks
several times, w/ Christine faking a switch on one occasion. It’s a more
common trope than I realized; it’s not just The Princess Bride that has
played with the trope.
There is no shortage of great moments; not
even Moe injuring his ankle stopped the shoot. It’s obvious in the
final few minutes but I guess the short must go on.”
By remake
standards, this was swell; Shemp will be missed. Next time, the start of
the four Fake Shemp shorts-why it happened and why they all have a
poor reputation.
Rumpus in the Harem:
(Short # 171 in Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk: The Columbia Shorts of The Three Stooges)
This
is the first of the four Fake Shemp shorts the Stooges did before the
brief Joe Besser era ended the long run they had at Columbia. They were
required to fulfill a contract and provide four more efforts, nevermind
Shemp having the temerity to unexpectedly drop dead via heart attack…
that's the cold-hearted take Columbia must have had. I’ll explain the
Fake Shemp term for those unaware at the end but for now, the short that
remade Malice in the Palace, one of the four public domain Stooges out
there & related to them in the Middle East.
They had a
stand-in for Shemp—longtime supporting player Joe Palma. In the new
scenes, it’s all Shemp not there, or it’s Fake Shemp’s back. Honestly,
how insulting; it’s all so obvious. In Rumpus, there’s the new storyline
that they need the Rootin-Tootin Diamond, else their girls will be sold
into slavery to pay off a McGuffin debt not worth explaining here. This
does have Malice’s most memorable (and morbidly funny) scene: everyone
else thinking Larry slaughtered a cat & dog then served it as food.
Not
that there aren’t some chuckles in the new scenes, but the old footage
isn’t always used well to tell a cohesive tale (more than once, things
suddenly happen & it'll be odd if you don’t remember or have seen
Malice before) and there’s no need to see this instead of the original…
unless you want to laugh at Palma as Fake Shemp attempting imitate Shemp
yelling a line; it was far from convincing, to say the least. The fact
that they obviously used lines from earlier shorts said by Shemp in an
attempt to make it appear not so phony—I shouldn’t complain due to the
example just listed by me.
As for the term Fake Shemp, of course
some will know it’s from Stooge fan Sam Raimi. He first used the term
for the stand-ins used during the long, arduous shoot of The Evil Dead.
Since then, the term has been used in a loving sense for either
stand-ins or bit players.
Fuelin' Around:
(Short # 172 in Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk: The Columbia Shorts of The Three Stooges)
To
start off… I just realized now that I made an embarrassing mistake in
my review for Fuelin’ Around, the short that Hot Stuff remade. While
re-reading that, I realized that additional unneeded text was
accidentally present. That’s now been taken out of that review; boy, do I
feel like a Stooge now! 2025 has just been an odd, off-kilter year for
me as I might elaborate upon sometime in the future.
I would have
rated Hot Stuff higher—if not for the ghoulish nature of this being a
Fake Shemp short. The new footage either shows Joe Palma as Shemp from
the back or in the opening, wearing a fake beard as a disguise to match
his cohorts. They found ways to separate him from Moe & Larry doing
routines with each other. At least there’s only two more of these to go
until the Joe Besser era begins.
This new scenario has the trio as
spies working for the country of Urania (no kidding, they have a
newspaper known as THE DAILY BLADDER; that did make me laugh) who are
undercover as carpet layers-instead of them being solely carpet layers
as they were in the original-in the house of a Dr. Sneed, as portrayed
by Emil Sitka. Spies from Anemia confuse Larry for Sitka, the trio are
kidnapped, and the usual hijinks occur.
The new footage is fine
(Moe and Larry engage in sexual harassment by forcing themselves onto
secretaries-before you cancel them, at least the women punish them for
being such cads) but as I’ve said ad nauseum by this point, the original
is preferable.
Scheming Schemers:
(Short # 173 in Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk: The Columbia Shorts of The Three Stooges)
A
lot happens with this short. It is a remake of 1949’s Vagabond Loafers,
the Shemp plumbing entry which itself used stock footage of the
all-time classic A Plumbing We Will Go, one of the best that Curly ever
did. In addition, there’s a random pie fight (which IMO doesn’t really
fit with the rest of the short) which has some new material but also
uses some bits from 1947’s Half-Wits Holiday, i.e. the last short Curly
starred in. Mix in some dubbed lines to try and tie in all this footage,
and a lot happens.
A shame that I didn’t like it better and not
everything ties together in a logical fashion. As before, “plumbing” is
the blue-collar job they have now. This time, they are called to
retrieve a ring dropped down the drain. The new footage involving that
did make me laugh, although it was obvious that Shemp wasn’t around.
Incidentally, Fake Shemp wasn’t even seen except for a few moments.
There’s still the subplot of an expensive painting being stolen during a
soiree being held at the same time.
This is kind of a mess, which
is a shame as there are chuckles throughout. Stooge fans believe this
is the best of the four Fake Shemp shorts, which to be frank is like
being the nicest person in prison! One moment late is one that some
Stooge fans object to. Moe and Larry are together and they ask where
Shemp is. He’s upstairs in a bathroom; the other two realize this so…
they look up to the heavens. Yep, I can understand why some may feel
that is insensitive at best. Who knows how they felt about that moment.
Commotion on the Ocean:
(Short # 174 in Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk: The Columbia Shorts of The Three Stooges)
The
last Fake Shemp short, the last time Shemp was in any Columbia short,
and there’s only 16 more of these until the long run the Stooges had at
Columbia came to an end. The short Joe Besser era is not beloved by most
Stooge fans but I’ll discuss that in a few days when I do another one
of these.
This entry uses plenty of footage from 1949’s Dunked in
the Deep; that has the trio as neighbors for a spy known as Borscht; to
copy and paste from that review:
“He hides microfilm of
“government documents” in… watermelons. The Stooges are his neighbor; as
they were victims of circumstances, they ended up stowaways on the same
aquatic vessel, a shipping frigate, to be exact. Believe it or not, the
watermelons conceit was a relevant reference. Those familiar w/ Alger
Hiss (who worked for the American government but was accused of being a
Soviet spy… the validity of those charges have never been proven or
disproven), it’d take way too long to explain here but rolls of 35mm
film were found in a hollowed-out pumpkin on his farm, purportedly to
send to the Soviet Union.”
In Commotion, the trio are janitors who
work at a newspaper office. They receive a call about the microfilm;
that footage is taken from 1948’s Crime on Their Hands… the way Joe
Palma as Fake Shemp OBVIOUSLY hid his face was so goofy that at least
made me laugh. The other new moments, Shemp’s absence was obvious. The
big new moment involved Moe, Larry and Borscht eating a taxidermized
fish via contrivances & it was a lesser version of gags they
used before.
The editing to tie all those moments together wasn’t
bad; thus, I can’t get too mad at Commotion. At the same time, for all
the faults that the Besser era has, at least except for a few moments,
those shorts will be all-new. More than one will be bad but at least the
stock footage is a thing of the past and I will have more to discuss.