66% on Rotten Tomatoes (out of 337 reviews)
Runtime: A LONG 197 minutes
Directed by: James Cameron
Starring: The usual faces, plus the true highlight in an underutilized Oona Chaplin
From: 20th Century Studios
No one's more surprised than me that I was finally let down by a James Cameron film.
Prefacing needs to occur first. This would have been watched sooner after release like I did with the first two-my schedule prevented that for a variety of reasons. It wasn't a lack of interest-simplistic plots aside, the first two Avatar movies were enjoyable. The audio and especially the visuals were naturally the standouts but I didn't mind the plots. Regrettably, that changed this time. The audience experience at the IMAX 3D screening wasn't the greatest-however, even if I was alone viewing the film on the world's largest IMAX screen, my opinion likely would be the same.
A huge problem: while I still enjoy the kids (including Spider)-constant usage of “bro” aside-this time around, I shouldn't be hating both Jake Sully and his old lady, yet that's what occurred here. Both were idiotic, insufferable fools who made moronic choice after moronic choice. So was the tribe from the second film, whose domicile they were still residing at. Before anyone retorts, yes I realize that they (along with the Ash tribe introduced in this movie) were the most blatant examples of the Native American allegory Cameron has always pushed. That did not make for an entertaining movie, IMO.
That Ash tribe-especially their badass lady leader Varang-were captivating. I understood their motivations and she was a dominant badass. Unfortunately, they then suddenly weren't so captivating and that was a major letdown. Many bad, baffling choices were made throughout, the number of convenient moments utterly staggering. In addition, even by Cameron standards, some of the dialogue and one-liners were rather putrid, especially for the scenarios where those lines were uttered. The fact that it seemed like little had changed from The Way of Water and the movie too often felt like a rehash of The Way of Water: that was also a huge issue.
This time around, the audio/visual component and some entertaining action did not make up for the plot (which constantly spun its wheels and felt totally stale compared to the grandeur of the first two pictures) and characters. Furthermore, for a movie 197 minutes in length, I shouldn't have felt like scenes were missing, so jagged was the story at times. I shouldn't have been confused so often at how we got from one scene to the next. An additional issue was how the movie felt longer than Satantango-RIP Bela Tarr.
All that plus an utterly preposterous final 15 to 20 minutes before the end credits finally hit-there's no need for me to ever watch the film in full again. Of course, I left as soon as those end credits rolled; to make another unpopular comment, I wanted to avoid the “song” from the utterly loathsome Miley Cyrus, the former Blackface artist and perpetually disgusting, vile creature. At least I can laugh that she looks like a 50-year old woman now!
But back on topic... Oona Chaplin and Stephen Lang are innocent of all charges. They share none of the blame for the failings of the film. As I've said too often in recent years, I'm glad that most others love the film but sadly, that love can't be shared by me. Aside from nice visuals and characters that were interesting at first, I'm happy to forget most of Fire & Ash.